Removing a Lis Pendens From a California Property Sale
A single page recorded at the county recorder’s office can freeze a California home sale cold, even if the underlying lawsuit behind it never has a chance of winning.
That page is a lis pendens — a notice of pending action — and once it is recorded against a property’s title, almost no lender will fund a purchase and almost no title company will insure one until it is resolved.
Here is exactly what the law requires to record one, how a seller gets one removed, and what it actually takes to win that fight.
What a Lis Pendens Actually Is
Under California Code of Civil Procedure section 405.20, a party to a lawsuit who asserts a “real property claim” — meaning the lawsuit itself seeks to affect title to, or possession of, a specific piece of real estate — can record a notice of pendency of action identifying the property and the names of everyone involved in the case.
The notice itself does not require a judge’s advance approval to record in most cases; a party can record it unilaterally as soon as the underlying lawsuit is filed, as long as the complaint actually pleads a real property claim and the statute’s signing and mailing requirements are satisfied.
Once recorded, the lis pendens gives every subsequent buyer, lender, or anyone else dealing with the property constructive notice of the pending lawsuit — legally, they are treated as if they already knew about the dispute even if nobody told them directly.
If the claimant eventually wins the underlying case, their rights relate back to the date the lis pendens was recorded, which is exactly why a title company will not insure a sale over an active one: insuring the buyer’s title would mean insuring against a claim the insurer already knows could prevail and could reach back in time to undo the very transaction it is insuring.
Not Every Lawsuit Qualifies for One
The statute’s requirement that the underlying case assert a “real property claim” is doing real work, and it screens out a lot of lawsuits that simply involve real estate in some loose sense.
A lawsuit seeking only money damages — a breach of contract claim over a failed sale, for instance, where the plaintiff wants compensation rather than the property itself or a lien against it — generally does not support a lis pendens, even if the dispute is entirely about a house.
The claim has to seek to directly affect title to, or the right to possession of, the specific property, which is why claims like partition, quiet title, specific performance of a contract to purchase real estate, foreclosure of an existing lien, or a claim to set aside a fraudulent transfer of the property itself are the kinds of cases that typically support one, while a claim that is really about money with real estate only in the background typically does not.
This distinction matters on an expungement motion, because a property owner can sometimes win outright by showing the underlying complaint never actually pleaded a real property claim in the first place, without even reaching the probable-validity question. That kind of pleading-based challenge can resolve faster than a full evidentiary fight over the merits of the underlying dispute, since it turns on reading the complaint itself rather than presenting competing evidence.
Recording One Without a Valid Claim Carries Its Own Risk
A person who records a lis pendens is not acting without consequence if the claim turns out to be unfounded.
Beyond losing the attorney’s fees fight under section 405.38 described below, a claimant who records a notice they knew or should have known lacked any real property claim behind it can face a separate claim for damages — sometimes framed as slander of title or malicious prosecution of the lis pendens itself — if the recording caused the property owner a demonstrable loss, such as a buyer walking away from an accepted purchase agreement.
This risk is part of why attorneys who understand the statute are generally cautious about recording a lis pendens purely as settlement leverage in a dispute that is really about money rather than the property itself; doing so can expose their client to liability well beyond the underlying lawsuit if the strategy backfires at an expungement hearing.
Where This Shows Up in a Home Sale
Lis pendens notices surface constantly in exactly the kinds of disputes that bring people to a cash-sale conversation in the first place. A sibling who disagrees with how an inherited house is being divided can record one while a partition action plays out.
A spouse in a contested divorce can record one against the family home to prevent the other spouse from selling or refinancing it before the court divides community property.
A contractor or lender who believes they have an equitable interest in a property — as opposed to a straightforward recorded lien — can sometimes use one instead of, or in addition to, a mechanic’s lien.
In every one of these situations, the notice does not require the underlying claim to actually be strong; it only requires the lawsuit to plead a real property claim on its face, which is a very low bar to clear at the moment of filing.
That low bar for recording is precisely why the law gives property owners a fast, specific tool to challenge a lis pendens that does not deserve to be clouding their title — because without one, anyone could tie up anyone else’s property indefinitely just by filing a weak lawsuit and recording a notice against it.
The Expungement Motion: Who Has to Prove What
Code of Civil Procedure section 405.30 puts the burden of proof squarely on the person who recorded the lis pendens, not on the property owner trying to get rid of it.
Section 405.32 then sets the standard: the court has to order the notice expunged if the claimant fails to establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, the “probable validity” of the underlying real property claim.
In plain terms, the claimant has to show it is more likely than not that they will actually win on the merits of the claim — not just that the claim is arguable or was filed in good faith, but that the evidence available at the hearing genuinely supports the claimant prevailing.
This is a meaningfully higher bar than what it took to record the notice in the first place, and that gap is intentional. Recording only requires a complaint that pleads the right kind of claim on its face; keeping the notice recorded once it is challenged requires actual evidence.
A lawsuit that sounds serious on paper but cannot produce supporting documents, witnesses, or other evidence at the expungement hearing typically loses the motion, and losing it means the notice comes off the property’s title regardless of how the rest of the underlying lawsuit eventually turns out.
The Alternative Path: Posting a Bond Instead
Even when a claimant can show probable validity and would otherwise survive an expungement motion, Code of Civil Procedure section 405.34 gives the property owner a second option: moving the court for an order expunging the notice in exchange for the claimant posting an undertaking, in whatever amount the court determines to be just.
This motion can be filed regardless of whether an expungement motion based on probable validity has also been filed, which means a seller facing a genuinely plausible claim is not necessarily stuck waiting out the entire lawsuit — if the claimant’s real interest is money rather than the specific property, a bond sized to cover that interest can let the sale proceed while the underlying case continues.
If the claimant does not comply with the court’s order to post the required undertaking by the date set, the court expunges the notice without any further hearing.
Attorney’s Fees Are on the Table
Section 405.38 requires the court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to whichever party prevails on an expungement motion, unless the losing party acted with substantial justification or the court finds an award would otherwise be unjust. This fee-shifting rule changes the calculation for both sides.
A claimant who recorded a lis pendens on a thin legal theory, hoping the mere existence of the cloud on title would pressure a settlement, risks having to pay the property owner’s attorney’s fees on top of losing the notice itself if the motion fails.
A property owner, in turn, has real financial leverage to push back against a lis pendens rather than simply waiting for the underlying case to resolve on its own schedule.
How Long an Expungement Motion Actually Takes
An expungement motion is designed to move faster than ordinary civil litigation, but “faster” still typically means weeks rather than days once notice periods, a hearing date on the court’s own calendar, and any evidentiary submissions are accounted for.
In a county with a congested civil calendar, getting an actual hearing date can itself take longer than the statute’s underlying intent of providing quick relief, which is one reason the alternative bond-based path under section 405.34 sometimes resolves faster in practice than fighting the probable-validity question outright — posting a bond does not require convincing a judge the underlying claim is weak, only that a dollar amount can adequately protect whatever interest the claimant is really asserting.
A seller under real time pressure, such as one already committed to a buyer with a financing contingency on a fixed closing date, should weigh both paths against the calendar realities of the specific court the case is pending in, not just against the legal merits of each option in the abstract.
What Happens to an Already-Accepted Purchase Offer
A lis pendens recorded after a seller has already accepted an offer does not automatically void the purchase agreement, but it almost always stalls the closing, because the buyer’s lender will refuse to fund and the title company will refuse to issue a clean policy while the notice sits on record.
Buyers using conventional financing typically cannot wait out an expungement motion, let alone an entire lawsuit, and many purchase contracts give the buyer an outright right to cancel once a title defect like this surfaces during the contingency period.
A seller in this position is often racing two clocks at once: the buyer’s patience, and the time it takes to either win an expungement motion or resolve the underlying dispute directly with the person who recorded the notice.
How a Lis Pendens Differs From an Ordinary Lien
A recorded lien, like a mortgage, a judgment lien, or a mechanic’s lien, secures a specific, calculable debt and can usually be resolved simply by paying it off at closing.
A lis pendens is different: it does not secure a debt at all, and there is often no dollar figure a seller can simply pay to make it go away, because the underlying lawsuit is about who actually owns the property or has the right to possess it, not about money owed.
That distinction is exactly why a title company treats the two so differently — a payoff demand clears a lien in a single escrow instruction, while a lis pendens requires either winning the expungement fight, posting a bond under section 405.34, or resolving the underlying lawsuit itself before title can be insured clean.
Sellers who have dealt with ordinary liens before sometimes assume a lis pendens will behave the same way and are surprised to learn that writing a check does not make it disappear.
Recording a Second Notice After the First Is Removed
Once a lis pendens has been expunged, the same claimant cannot simply record a second one against the same property based on the same claim without first getting the court’s permission under Code of Civil Procedure section 405.36.
California courts have treated this rule seriously — a 2024 published appellate decision specifically addressed an attempt to re-record after an earlier notice was expunged, reinforcing that section 405.36’s permission requirement is not a formality a determined claimant can simply route around by filing again on their own.
For a property owner who has already been through one expungement fight, that rule is meaningful protection against having to relitigate the exact same issue indefinitely.
When Fighting the Notice Beats Selling Around It
A fast cash sale is not automatically the smarter move just because it can close around a lis pendens a financed buyer would walk away from.
If the underlying claim is genuinely weak — the complaint arguably pleads no real property claim, or the claimant has little evidence to offer at a hearing — an expungement motion can resolve the whole problem in weeks and clear the way for an ordinary, fully priced listing instead of a sale negotiated around an unresolved cloud on title.
Section 405.38’s fee-shifting rule makes that fight more worthwhile when the claim looks thin, since a seller who wins can recover the fees spent getting there.
Selling to a cash buyer comfortable taking on the dispute makes more sense when the claim has real substance and could take months to resolve, when the claimant does in fact have supporting evidence, or when a deadline — a probate closing, a pending foreclosure, a pressing need for the equity — makes waiting out even a successful motion impractical.
A seller who hasn’t talked to an attorney about how strong the claim actually is should do that first, since a notice that looks intimidating on the title report is sometimes easy to remove.
What a Seller Should Do the Moment One Shows Up
Checking a preliminary title report before listing is the single most effective way to catch a lis pendens before it derails an accepted offer rather than during escrow, since a notice recorded months earlier in an unrelated dispute can sit quietly on title until a buyer’s title search finally surfaces it.
If a notice is already recorded, or gets recorded after a purchase agreement is signed, confirming with the title company exactly what they need to see resolved — a successful expungement, a settlement and dismissal, or a bonded release under section 405.34 — tells a seller which of the paths above actually fits the situation, rather than guessing.
An attorney familiar with the specific type of underlying claim, whether it is a partition dispute between heirs, a divorce-related community property claim, or a contractor’s equitable claim, is worth retaining quickly here, because the expungement motion’s evidentiary burden is exactly the kind of fight where preparation and documentation decide the outcome.
Selling With a Lis Pendens Still Attached
A conventional, financed buyer is rarely willing to close with an active lis pendens still on title, which leaves a seller choosing between resolving the notice first and finding a buyer who does not need mortgage financing or a standard title policy to move forward.
A cash buyer comfortable taking on a property with a documented path to clearing the notice — a pending settlement, a scheduled expungement hearing, or a bond already approved — can sometimes close around a dispute that would otherwise sit unresolved for months while a financed deal falls apart and gets relisted.
If you’re dealing with a California property that has a lis pendens recorded against it, whether from a contractor dispute, a contested inheritance, or a divorce, you can reach us by calling (424) 435-2326, through our Google Business Profile, or at cashhomebuyersca.com — we buy directly or bring a vetted cash buyer who already understands how to work around a clouded title instead of simply walking away from it.
When you sell to us, we pay the standard closing costs, including the county and city transfer taxes, escrow and title.
